Author: Ioan VOICU
A BOOK REVIEW: NICOLAE IORGA AND POLAND, ROMÂNIA DE MÂINE FOUNDATION PUBLISHING HOUSE, BUCHAREST, 2021
Nicolae Iorga (1871-1940), member of the Romanian Academy and president of the History Section (1924-1927), is an emblematic personality of the Romanian life. Unparalleled historian and theorist of this discipline, highly prestigious professor, translator, writer with representative works in all literary genres, journalist, publisher, editor, diplomat and politician, Iorga has contributed decisively to consolidating the cultural unity of Romanians everywhere.
On the occasion of the 150th anniversary of the birth of the greatest Romanian historian – Nicolae Iorga –, it is worth remembering the words of the President of the Romanian Academy, Constantin Rădulescu-Motru, who, in his funeral speech from 1940, at the passing of Nicolae Iorga, he defined him as “a legendary figure” who would gain in grandeur as time went on.
The current grandeur of Nicolae Iorga is convincingly illustrated by the recently published volume signed by Nicolae Mareș under the title Nicolae Iorga and Poland, Bucharest, Romania of Tomorrow Foundation Publishing House.
The result of a long research, this book covers in 226 pages an essential chapter of the activity of the great Romanian scientist in the service of cooperation and friendship between the Romanian and Polish peoples.
The very mention of the titles of some chapters and sections of this book, divided into four substantial parts, is a convincing testimony of the richness of ideas and analyses generated by an exceptional documentation on the tireless work of Nicolae Iorga dedicated to Romanian-Polish relations, until the outbreak of World War II.
Here are some suggestive and illuminating examples of titles: The Polish flag – the one sacredly guarded in Romania – glorified by Iorga, when Poland was erased from the map; Iorga in the face of the terrible Polish fatality of 1939; A sincere Moldavian friendship towards the sympathetic, plagued by fate, Poles who arrived in the Romanian lands; Polish Foreign Minister Beck – in the role of conciliator or mediator – between Hungary and Romania; Horthy’s visit to Poland – the first attempt to “dislocate the Little Understanding”; Romania was advised by Poles “to buy Hungary at the expense of Czechoslovakia” – agreeing to offer Ukraine Subcarpathia to Hungarians; Romania’s perplexity about the joint Polish-Hungarian actions; Romania’s firm response to the bastard solutions put into circulation by Warsaw; Bucharest asks Belgrade to show solidarity with Romanian efforts; Warsaw was aware that the whole Europe was against it; Beck’s duplicity in relations with Romania will be maintained; The revisionist campaign of two million Hungarians in America, Italy, Great Britain; The Romanian-language lectureship in Krakow; Honorary member of the Krakow Academy of Sciences; Iorga wrote thousands of pages about Poland and Romanian-Polish relations; Unparalleled analysis in his journalism about Poland; Poland defends its being and its ancestral land; The brother’s sufferings deserve relief; Iorga about Eminescu at the Jagiellonian University; The first Eminescu poems in Mickiewicz’s language prefaced by Iorga; Moral obligations for Poland.
The volume ends with an impressive section on the political will of Nicolae Iorga, an extensive bibliography and a useful index of names.
The breadth and diversity of the material treated in this book do not allow a detailed presentation of its content, of some events brought for the first time to the attention of the Romanian reading public. Romanian and Polish historians are invited to continue to speak on about this topic. We will limit ourselves to highlighting Nicolae Iorga’s conception of the place of good neighbourliness and solidarity in relations between Romania and Poland and the value of this humanist conception in the vast sphere of bilateral and multilateral diplomacy.
We will first treat the neighbourliness, benefiting from the fact that Nicolae Mareș makes it known to us through the very words of Nicolae Iorga, to which are added the pertinent comments of the author of this book.
Historically, we are reminded that in 1917 the publicist Iorga would write in Neamul Românesc one of the most beautiful hymns to the Polish flag and Polish manhood in the fights that took place around the world: “In Galati, the Polish flag, Iorga wrote, of the white eagle that overcame the Teutonic prey cross so many times and guarded the entire East – both Russian and Romanian – from German conquest was raised. He fluttered proudly and freely, enthusiastically acclaimed by the noble soldiers in arms with eyes full of tears at the sight of their country coming out of the grave. And from the beginning it found a comrade in the flag of Romania, who also struggled and still struggles on so many fields of martyrdom of the people represented by it. Side by side, in brotherly closeness, they announced to us a guarantee of the future for our tormented and sacrificed people.” The Polish people are defined by Nicolae Iorga in this article as “a neighbour to whom we are connected by so many older traditions, in addition to essential elements in the very soul of these two nations, a gentle feeling, a devotion to the ideal, a deep contempt for the overwhelming force of raw matter” (p. 23). An authentic hymn to good neighbourliness.
Critically continuing his idea in another context, Nicolae Iorga does not shy away from reminding that for the Romanians, “The idea of national unity – without a mixture of feudalism, for which the historical ties and the dispositions of spirit, the corresponding moods were missing –, could not be borrowed entirely from the neighbours, the Balkans being ruled by the Roman imperial dream of the Slavic countries, and those over the mountains having for their kings, former Slavic fashion voivodes, the Carolingian model of the West, with the blessing, indispensable, from the pope” (p. 207). Nicolae Mareș does not fail to inform the readers that these aspects are treated extensively by Nicolae Iorga in the work România, vecinii săi și chestiunea Orientului (p. 154).
From all the volumes, studies and articles of Nicolae Iorga, the distinguished author of the book analyzed in these lines draws an essential conclusion: “The great Romanian historian and creator not only knew very well the Polish history and culture, but, since childhood, he showed special love and appreciation to our north-western neighbours. The historian, the great scholar, the statesman, the writer was the one who cultivated and militated like no other to establish the best possible relations of knowledge and cooperation between the two countries and peoples, between their cultures” (p. 112).
Developing and arguing this conclusion, Nicolae Mareș invites the readers to navigate the entire activity of Nicolae Iorga put at the service of the good neighbourliness between Romania and Poland. He points out that “In the more than 1,000 books and tens of thousands of studies, articles and reviews, N. Iorga is the historian, writer, publicist, who wrote and published thousands of pages about Poland and the Romanian-Polish relations. He even researched and elaborated on Poland’s relations with other states, presenting them with rare meticulousness, in a universal context. The attempts of contemporaries and descendants, all together, failed to highlight the in-depth approach taken to Poland from within by the great propagator of Polish history, culture and spirituality, and especially the sensitive joints of his efforts. Iorga’s writings and appreciations of the Poles and their homeland wear a neo-romantic mantle, easily overcoming some of the known sins of Moldova’s northern neighbour. These feelings have been perpetuated for decades in his soul.
Nicolae Mareș brings this subject to the present day and informs: “It is with great regret that contemporary Polish historians do not know Iorga and have done nothing to propagate and understand him. They have not vouchsafed for 80 years since his passing into eternity to publish even a brief collection of the most important studies, of his analyses of bilateral issues of interest, collected by the tireless researcher through Polish archives, admittedly, today under Ukrainian rule” (p. 105).
The Romanian-Polish relations are not analyzed by Nicolae Mareș only in the light of the academic contributions we inherited from Nicolae Iorga. He brings us into a space of useful debate and Romania’s official position, expressed diplomatically by the Romanian minister of Foreign Affairs. Thus, it is recalled that, on December 29, 1938, Grigore Gafencu presented an exposition on Bucharest radio in which he stroked a balance of the Romanian international policy of that period, addressing the issue of Romania’s relations with its neighbours. He stated: “Romania fulfils its peaceful duties towards its neighbours and with all the States that surround it on the basis of a complete independence and its full territorial integrity. They are goods earned with blood and rightly so. They are a holy part of the world. No Romanian will allow them to be harassed. Keeping away from the ideological currents that trouble and sometimes bleed Europe, Romania will resolutely reject any outside interference in its state affairs, as well as any conspiracy that would tend to disturb its thinking and life, to weaken the settlements, the power of defence, the unity of the soul and its faith in the free fulfilment of its high mission” (p. 85).
In the matter of good neighbourliness, the Romanian diplomats followed with justified attention all the steps, initiatives and plans of the Polish state. Thus, the diplomat Richard Franasovici, former interior minister, writes a report that he sends directly to the king, but also to minister Petrescu-Comnen. In this report, Franasovici confirms that he was better informed than the new Romanian ambassador in Poland. Richard Franasovici states in his report, among other things, that “Compared to Czechoslovakia, Poland intends to inaugurate a good neighbourly policy, seeking to channel neighbouring republic through the port of Gdynia” (p. 64).
For a more nuanced characterization of Poland’s position towards its neighbours, Nicolae Mareș also appeals to foreign historians contemporary with the events evoked in the book. In this context, it is recalled that the English historian Normand Davies revealed – among Poland’s most dishonourable actions –, ultimatum given to Lithuania in March 1938 and the occupation of Zaolzia in October. Normand Davies points out that: “…the Polish authorities took advantage of the misfortunes of their neighbours to resolve old disputes and to congratulate themselves, but the government’s main concern was not to be surrounded by Germany on the southern and northern flanks.” These actions are far from understanding the concept of goodwill at that time and in contradiction with the interpretation of this concept today.
Good neighbourliness postulates the fulfilment of the solidarity duty between neighbours. It is an undeniable truth in the interwar period and fully valid in the 21st century. The historian Nicolae Iorga was fully aware of the validity of this truth, and Nicolae Mareș widely evoked the circumstances in which Nicolae Iorga gave expression to his feelings of solidarity with the Polish people. The section entitled Solidarity with Poland manifested by Nicolae Iorga in 1939 bears witness to the way in which the magic of good neighbourhood harmonizes with the imperative of solidarity in Nicolae Iorga’s thinking. “’We do not find ourselves in the presence of a declarative solidarity, but of a call for a firm and large-scale solidarity action,’ the author of the book explains this attitude. With the outbreak of the Second World War, in September 1939, until the last moments of his life, N. Iorga wrote, in Neamul Românesc and in other publications of the time, dozens of articles in which he proclaimed the outbreak of the world conflagration, depicting the drama of the people so close to us, forced to leave their ancestral hearth, in the face of the Nazi attack and bombing in the west and the Bolsheviks in the east… In the given situation, Iorga addressed, to all Romanians: ‘from the bishop to the opinca’, hot calls to support, with all the best, the afflicted Polish brothers. (p. 87). As a matter of fact, Nicolae Mareș considered this subject of crucial importance in the relations between Romania and Poland and he dedicated an entire monograph to it: Nicolae Mareș, Alianța româno-polonă între destrămare și solidaritate, Biblioteca Publishing House, Bucharest, 2010.
Nicolae Iorga analyses, in an international context, solidarity as a universal value, as it will be defined many years later by the United Nations, on September 8th, 2000, in the Millennium Declaration which states expressis verbis: “Solidarity. Global challenges must be managed in a way that correctly distributes costs and burdens in accordance with the basic principles of equity and social justice. Those who suffer or benefit the least deserve help from those who benefit the most”.
Referring to moral solidarity, Nicolae Iorga points out: “Moral solidarity (;) means first recognizing the need for goals that everyone must worship with their faith and work, ready to face any dangers and receive all suffering. [….] However, this solidarity needs to be managed, and the leaders should not be blindly sought at the moment of threats, such as, again, the changeable connection with them is not of a material calculation. They must always be at the place where the signal word is given, and this word must not be sought in the buds through all the corners of darkness. The hierarchy of functions should correspond as much as possible with the natural hierarchy of values and merits, so that the guide does not become more insecure than those who are required to be guided” (p. 216).
The reading of Nicolae Mareș’ book highlights not only the passion and meticulousness demonstrated by the author in the in-depth research of a topic of major interest for the history of relations between Romania and Poland, but also highlights the unilateral nature of the attention paid to Nicolae Iorga’s contribution to promoting friendship between peoples. Polish historians have not found it appropriate to respond on the basis of reciprocity to the Romanian invitation to create academically useful bridges for better knowledge of the history of the two countries, especially in the periods of hardship that the Romanians and the Poles went through. Not even the alliance of the two countries in the organization of the Warsaw Pact, in the European Union and in NATO has stimulated joint research plans or individual projects of mutual interest in this specific field.
We hope that the English and Polish translation of Nicolae Mareș’ book will make it easier for historians in Poland and Romania to take on the intellectual responsibility of clearing gaps in the history of their countries’ bilateral relations.
This desideratum should, moreover, be examined from a broader perspective. Nicolae Iorga wrote the first history of Albania, which was used as documentary material at the Paris Peace Conference, where the independence of this country was recognized. Historically, the first fundamental works in Romanian historiography on the relations between Romania and many countries belong to him, among which a significant place is occupied by those dedicated to the relations with neighbouring states. These truths should be known by international public opinion. Nicolae Iorga should be converted, without delay, into electronic editions, easily disseminated worldwide.
The example offered by Nicolae Mareș through the volume of authentic pioneering presented in these brief lines should be followed by professional historians, who should fully capitalize on the huge documentary and interpretative legacy left by Nicolae Iorga. According to the latest data published or updated at June 5th, 2021 in an encyclopaedic article published by Wikipedia, Nicolae Iorga is defined as a “wonder child, polymath and polyglot, with a prolific scientific activity.” It is estimated that Iorga wrote 1,003 volumes, 12,755 articles and studies and 4,963 reviews, this unequalled activity culminating with Istoria României, in ten volumes. The widest possible knowledge of this immense work, through both individual and collective efforts, would represent the most brilliant and well-deserved homage to Nicolae Iorga and his patrimony to the universal culture.
IOAN VOICU: Doctor of Political Science from the University of Geneva (1968), doctor honoris causa in international law from the Assumption University of Thailand (1998), career diplomat; Romania’s Deputy Representative to the United Nations Security Council (1990-1991); member of the Administrative Court of the United Nations (1987-1993), Romanian ambassador to the Kingdom of Thailand and permanent observer with international organizations based in Bangkok (1994-1999), associate professor at Assumption University in Thailand (2000-2019).
813475 618312You made some decent factors there. I looked on the internet for the dilemma and located most individuals will go along with together with your website. 357867
770095 783183You produced some great points there. I did a search on the subject and discovered many people will agree along with your blog. 168154
109215 657203Today, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a 25 foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is totally off topic but I had to share it with someone! 659264
Exactly what is the best Canon Powershot electronic (duh) camera? I are interested for mostly casual pictures (christmas, birthdays, family reunions that almost stuff). And occasionally a group of cool artistic photos. Im told than a 6-7 mm lens may be the best Other than in which, what else is very good???
707593 738312Hey, you used to write fantastic, but the last couple of posts have been kinda boring I miss your tremendous writings. Past few posts are just a little out of track! come on! 468136
406827 816901Howdy! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group? Theres a great deal of people that I believe would actually enjoy your content material. Please let me know. Thanks 874649
173730 101051Paris Hilton: So lovely spending time with Manny and h 557063
659234 938336Some times its a discomfort in the ass to read what people wrote but this internet site is real user genial ! . 152768
548681 281661Its good as your other content material : D, appreciate it for posting . 598996
296716 110723Wow What fantastic details. Thank you for the time you spent on this post. 858995
917543 508850Admiring the time and energy you put into your blog and in depth info you offer. Its good to come across a blog every once in a whilst that isnt the same old rehashed material. Amazing read! Ive bookmarked your site and Im adding your RSS feeds to my Google account. 200012
318447 104008I like this website so much, saved to favorites . 451149
875071 626559When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now every time a remark is added I get four emails with exactly the same comment. Is there any approach youll be able to remove me from that service? Thanks! 367543
957724 33726Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting videos to your site when you could be giving us something informative to read? 91046
244921 659370Yeah bookmaking this wasnt a high risk determination outstanding post! . 89359
682219 841313hello, i came in to learn about this topic, thanks alot. will put this internet site into my bookmarks. 849302
809321 756429I believe one of your adverts caused my internet browser to resize, you may well want to put that on your blacklist. 160920
716164 892003Its difficult to get knowledgeable folks on this subject, but the truth is be understood as what happens you are preaching about! Thanks 285357
395685 845931It can be difficult to write about this subject. I feel you did an superb job though! Thanks for this! 573952
451042 245984I visited a great deal of web site but I conceive this one holds something particular in it in it 544226
495782 438461I adore foregathering useful information, this post has got me even a lot more info! . 614320
315355 291075I conceive this web web site contains some rattling great information for everyone : D. 187059
512213 676250I surely didnt know that. Learnt 1 thing new these days! Thanks for that. 376894
455266 313673I conceive this web web site holds some real superb data for every person : D. 784060
119984 505675Thank you for having the time to discuss this subject. I truly appreciate it. Ill stick a link of this entry in my website. 57208
830351 920387Glad to be one of several visitors on this awing web site : D. 743461
247385 75227The Case For HIIT Cardio – Why You need to Concider it By the way you may want to look at this cool web site I found 991641
690957 952384Locating the right Immigration Solicitor […]below youll discover the link to some sites that we think you need to visit[…] 393743
921792 638202Glad to be 1 of numerous visitants on this awing web website : D. 237114
270978 126412I likewise conceive thus, perfectly written post! . 448860
735170 382636Fantastic post, I conceive site owners really should learn a lot from this web blog its rattling user genial . 892179
720010 503893Completely composed content material material , thankyou for information . 588124
141139 613407I like this weblog quite much, Its a rattling nice billet to read and discover information . 483168
729448 712924Your article is truly informative. Far more than that, it??s engaging, compelling and well-written. I would desire to see even far more of these types of fantastic writing. 41997
464018 96528thaibaccarat dot com could be the very best web site to study casino games : like baccarat, poker, blackjack and roulette casino 756771
193948 689972I took a break to view your write-up. I discovered it extremely relaxing 169370
708260 904070I actually like your writing style, fantastic details, thankyou for posting : D. 115465
269407 62678Fantastic process! 747078
780639 955391I want to thank you for the exceptional post!! I undoubtedly liked every bit of it. Ive bookmarked your internet website so I can take a appear at the latest articles you post later on. 972977
612959 636262Hmm is anyone else experiencing issues with the images on this weblog loading? Im trying to uncover out if its a problem on my finish or if it is the weblog. Any responses would be greatly appreciated. 174408
460054 29551It is difficult to get knowledgeable men and women within this topic, nevertheless, you appear to be guess what happens youre dealing with! Thanks 767995
543114 371256This internet website is actually a walk-through for all of the information you wanted about this and didnt know who to ask. Glimpse here, and youll definitely discover it. 803534
46220 231760I feel other website proprietors ought to take this internet site as an example , quite clean and amazing user genial style . 900892
938201 341175great publish, very informative. 439387
347528 686540Most heavy duty trailer hitches are developed utilizing cutting edge computer aided models and fatigue stress testing to ensure optimal strength. Share new discoveries along with your child and maintain your child safe by purchasing the correct style for your lifestyle by following the Perfect Stroller Buyers Guideline. 380604
943391 311666love your imagination!!!! wonderful function!! oh yeah.. cool photography too. 663896
371409 200430Just a smiling visitor here to share the really like (:, btw outstanding layout. 186937
390875 685360Read more on that great Post, I linked to you Thanks. 866757